Throttle and pedal assist are two ways the motor can help. Pedal assist works only while you turn the cranks. A throttle can move the bike without pedaling. I have ridden bikes with both, and bikes with pedal assist only. This is a buying choice, not a claim that one mode is always better.
What I actually use each one for
On a Class 2 bike, I use the throttle most when I am starting from a stop, especially with weight on the back, or when I want a short break without getting off the bike. In my classes guide I said pulling away from a stop sign with a kid on the deck is far easier with a throttle. The Aventure 3 I tested has a throttle on the left that works from zero, so you can pull away without pedaling, and it also has pedal assist. The Abound and the RadWagon 4, both Class 2 cargo bikes I have ridden, also have throttles that work from zero.
Pedal assist is the mode I use for normal riding, because it still feels like biking. You pedal, the motor adds power, and you can choose a lower or higher assist level. On the original Aventon Ramblas I rode, there is no throttle at all. It is a Class 1 mid-drive: the motor only helps while you pedal, up to 20 mph. I have only ridden the original Ramblas, not the later ADV.
If you want the legal and practical limits on riding with the motor and no pedaling, see can you ride an e-bike without pedaling.
How the classes split the two
Class 1 is pedal assist only, to 20 mph. Class 2 adds a throttle, with the motor stopping at 20 mph. Class 3 is pedal assist to 28 mph. The usual class definition says Class 3 assists only when you are pedaling. Some bikes sold as Class 3 still have a throttle, usually limited to 20 mph. That is a multiple-mode setup, and states do not all treat it the same way, so check yours. I go into the class split in Class 2 vs Class 3.
Buy a Class 1 bike if you want the motor only while you pedal, or if you ride places that allow pedal-assist bikes but not throttles. Buy a Class 2 bike if you want the option to move from a stop without pedaling. Which one fits depends on where you ride, not on a rule that everyone needs a throttle.
What pedal assist means is in what is pedal assist. Cadence versus torque sensors are a separate question.
Bikes mentioned
Related
Updated